A Vicious Cycle of Poppy Farming in Myanmar

A Vicious Cycle of Poppy Farming in Myanmar

WINEMAW (KACHIN STATE)

Yein May* in her mid-thirties holds high hopes that her opium producing poppy plantation will not be found and destroyed by authorities and is able to earn enough to keep her family fed and clothed for the next year.

Yein May and her husband grow poppies on almost an acre of a hillside field deep inside Winemaw Township – one of the illicit drug growing areas of Kachin State.

January is both a time of great hope and anxiety for Yein May and the villagers who live and harvest opium in the northern foothills of Kachin State that borders China.

Around the end of January, the poppies begin to blossom and decorate the remote and steep hillsides of the region. While the colorful flowers are signs of potential good fortune for the growers, they are also an inviting signal to local authorities that it is time to show-up and destroy the illicit crop.

Yein May, a mother of two, explains that her family’s poppy field will, hopefully, provide her hard-up household with enough rice for a year, if they are lucky enough to avoid the police and harvest enough opium from this year’s poppies.

Yein May says she swings between feelings of anxiety and hope, worried that her poppy farm could be destroyed by the local authorities.

“If our poppy farm is included on the list of those to be destroyed, how will we cope supplying our basic needs for the coming rainy season?” whispered Yein May, hugging her five-month-old baby, while sitting on the floor of her house.

There are thousands of poppy farmers like Yein May who grow opium poppies as their main cash crop. The picturesque, but remote poppy growing hills are home to Myanmar’s ethnic people, but for decades have been plagued with armed conflict.

The villagers are aware that the crop that they are growing is illicit and harmful, but claim they have limited choices or no viable alternative legal crops that they can grow.

Mawkun’s reporters talked to poppy farmers in three States to find out what are the driving factors for the increase in poppy cultivation, and why farmers continue to grow and trade their illicit crops.

Mawkun spoke to local community groups and international organizations to find out how the decade-old problem of opium trade could be reduced and rooted out.

CULTIVATION REMAINS HIGH

Despite efforts of the government to eradicate the problem, opium poppy cultivation has remained an insurmountable problem. This is especially so in Myanmar, regarded as one of the poorest Southeast Asian countries, but is the second largest opium producer in the world after Afghanistan.

Though poppy cultivation area harvested dropped to 21,600 hectares in 2006, it has since increased yearly and the size tripled in 2013 with an alarming 57,800 hectares being farmed. Though cultivation has stabilized since 2013, it remains high.

In its recent report, released in mid-December 2015, the United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime (UNODC) noted that opium poppy cultivation in Myanmar was estimated at 55,500 hectares in 2015 – a decrease of 4% from 2014.

According to the UNODC report, Shan State, bordering with Thailand and Laos, accounts for 91% of all of Myanmar’s cultivation, with Southern Shan State accounting for 42%, Eastern Shan State for 31%, and Northern Shan State for 17%. While Kachin State accounts for 8%, Kayah and Chin State each account for 1%.

The Country Manager for UNODC, Mr. Troels Vester, in an interview with Mawkun said, “There are a complex set of drivers for opium poppy cultivation, but food insecurity, poverty, and [armed] conflict or insecurity are amongst the important ones.”

Mr. Tom Kramer, a researcher with Transnational Institute (TNI), pointed out that most growers are impoverished farmers from ethnic minority communities who cultivate opium as a cash crop to address food shortages, to buy basic household items, and to get access to health and education for their children.

“In these [poppy-growing] areas, there is often no access to basic health care and essential medicines,” Mr. Kramer said, adding that communities use opium as a painkiller and medicine against diarrhea and other health problems.

Farmers in Shan, Kachin, and Kayah States told Mawkun that their remote geographical location pushes local people to choose poppy as a main crop,.

Farmers pointed out that before they switched to growing illicit crops, they grew corn, garlic, onions and potatoes on the steep hillsides where slash-and-burn farming is still commonly practiced.

Farmers in Hsi Hseng Township of Southern Shan State remember the backbreaking and exhaustion for carrying heavy bags and baskets of produces for the two-hour trek from their uphill plantations to their villages.

Farmers said that though they shouldered their produce from their farms to village, then from village to market, they did not get good prices for their efforts. In some years, they found no customers wanting to buy their produce and had to resort to throwing it away.

Because of such geographic difficulties and poor market accessibility, farmers choose poppy as their cash crop. When farmers compare the good and bad points of poppy with other crops, its good points outweigh the negative.

Farmers said that when they harvest the opium sap, they can easily carry it in a small basket, compared with heavy bags of corns or potatoes. Most importantly, farmers say the rewards from growing an illicit crop are greater compared to legal crops.

According to farmers, interviewed by Mawkun, they can earn at least 2 million kyats (about US$ 2,000) from one acre of poppy field each season.

As opium is profitable, farmers who used to grow cheroot leaves that are used to roll cigars have also switched to growing opium poppies in Southern Shan State. Farmers said that they earned around 600,000 Kyats from one acre of cheroot leaves each year, while they can get about two million Kyats (more than three times) from the same area of poppies, and they don’t need to work as hard.

Unlike other crops, farmers do not need to go to the market themselves to sell the raw poppy, opium buyers come and buy from their fields or at their homes.

HIGH RISKS

Though farmers get more money from the illicit crop, the investment they put in is larger than what they put in for legal crops. And they also have risks such as pests and extreme weather conditions that affect the yields.

In addition to these risks, famers say they also fear police. Farmers say police come to chop down when their poppy plants begin to bloom. In some areas, village headmen offer the police a poor quality yielding field for destruction so they can take photos or videos to show their senior officials in the country’s capital, Naypyitaw.

In Myanmar, growing opium poppy is illegal and growers can be given prison sentences. Despite the risk, poppy fields can be seen in abundance in ethnic areas, especially in the area controlled by militias and ethnic armed-groups.

In Kayah State, farmers said they have to pay a so-called ‘poppy tax’ to the village headmen who transfer the money to the police, militias or ethnic-armed groups. One acre of poppy field can be ‘taxed’ from 15,000 Kyats to 50,000 Kyats, depending on the quality of plants and potential yields, said farmers (who for safety concerns asked not to be named).

A village headman, from Demoso Township in Kayah State, (who asked to remain anonymous), told Mawkun, that the opium harvest time is his busiest time. The headman complained that it frustrated him to act as a negotiator between the villagers, local authorities and militia groups. He said because of the frustration and his reluctance to be involved in the negotiations he has decided not to run for a village headman position again.

“The government turns a blind eye to this issue,” He said.

Farmers in Kachin and Shan State agreed that they also have to pay ‘tax’ to local authorities, militia and ethnic groups, through their village headmen. Despite having to pay the money, they are not sure whether their poppy fields will be spared by police.

A village headman in charge of a small village situated on the hillside of the Maenal Mountain Range in the Pa-Oh Self-administered Zone counted the names of the groups his villagers have to pay ‘tax’ to. The list includes the army battalion and police station in the area, a military intelligent group, Special Branch, the Pa-Oh National Organization (PNO) and the Pa-Oh National Army (PNA).

“We have great fears,” said the village headman, “We’re afraid our poppy fields will be swept out if they [above-mentioned groups] are offended.”

When contacted by Mawkun, Win Ko, deputy chairman of PNO, denied the words of village headman and said over the phone that they do not officially tax the villagers. But he admitted that they may collect some money to build bridges and pave the road.

“When the budget given by the government for development projects is not enough, we collect money then,” he admitted.

The village headman also said that he had to deliver the villagers’ money to the compound of army battalion and police station.

“They treat me well. Not bad,” said the village headman, appreciating the way he was welcomed and accepted. “They just ask how much we can donate – for the wives and children of soldiers who are at the battle front.”

Mawkun emailed and phoned the Myanmar Army several times regarding the allegations of the villagers, but had not received any response from the Army until at the time of print.

In a meeting with Police Colonel San Lwin of Shan State, he said that police are instructed not to take bribes and just to crack down on poppy fields. However, he admitted that some police were taken actions for taking bribes.

Mawkun witnessed that while some poppy growing areas are the target of anti-narcotic police crackdowns, some areas are deemed safe.

Farmers growing poppies in the areas under the control of Restoration Council of Shan State (RCSS)/ Shan State Army-South (SSA-S) are confident that the authorities will not destroy their poppy fields.

RCSS/SSA-S is one of the eight ethnic armed-groups that signed the controversial Nationwide Ceasefire Agreement (NCA) last year with the Thein Sein government.

Farmers from Likekhar and Naungbo Zaykone villages in Namhsan Township said that in 2014 and 2015 the RCSS/SSA-S troops waited at the gate of their villages and collected 30,000 Kyats per viss (1.6 kg) of raw poppy.

If villagers were caught while avoiding the soldiers, all their raw poppy was taken, said the villagers. In addition to the RCSS/SSA-S, there is another militia group that waits and collects the tax. Villagers also said that they have to pay tax for their cars and grocery stores.

Lieutenant Colonel Sai Han of RCSS/SSA-S said that they do not have a policy of taxing opium. “Our policy doesn’t allow us to tax. If people have evidence (of collecting tax), they can report to us,” said the Lieutenant Colonel.

He also claimed that his organization wants to wipe out poppy cultivation.

VILLAGERS REMAIN UNCONVINCED

Though militia and ethnic-armed groups denied allegations of ‘tax collection’ and claimed that they also wanted to fight opium cultivation, local people were not convinced.

Local residents told Mawkun that ethnic groups and militia groups do not grow the poppy, but “what the people grow seems to belong to them [ethnic armed groups],” said a poppy farmer from Naungbo Zaykon village in Namhsan Township. “After we grow and harvest, they come and take [our money].”

In Namhsan Township alone, there are six militias and armed-groups, including the RCSS/SSA-S, PNA and Mon Tai Army (MTA). These armed groups exist because of the opium industry, said a poppy farmer. The farmer claimed that if there were no poppy fields, there would be no funding for the militia, which would in turn free the local people.

Another farmer said, “We wish the poppies disappeared. We just want an alternative crop to grow as a substitute for the poppies.”

Successive Myanmar governments have claimed that they have tried to eradicate poppy cultivation, and have launched a number of crop substitution programs. The most recent was a 15-year program from 1999 to 2014 that the government had carried out.

However, the program has been unsuccessful and was given an extra five years to prove itself.

Mr. Kramer of TNI said that instead of aiming for a ‘drug free’ region or country, the government should set more realistic and achievable policy aims.

“The government should focus on a development approach to address problems related to poppy cultivation, including poverty and conflict resolution,” he said.

Mr. Kramer suggested that the drug policy in Myanmar should move away from deadline oriented thinking and ‘drug free’ goals towards accepting and promoting harm reduction strategies for drug users and a development led approach to address problems related to opium cultivation.

In order to reduce poppy cultivation, the Myanmar government and the UNODC has implemented a pilot project, the ‘Alternative Development Program’ in two Shan State townships.

Under the ‘Alternative Development Program’, poppy farmers are persuaded to substitute poppy with coffee plants, as the global coffee market has ‘cash potential’.

“In order to create a real and sustainable change, the project creates farmer enterprises that in the future will be linked to premium international markets,” said Mr. Vester of UNODC.

The first farmer enterprise – Green Gold Coffee Cooperative – was constituted in July 2015, and currently has roughly 800 farmers as shareholders, said the UNODC official.

The Cooperative will be the link between the farmers and international markets, and will ensure high quality post-harvesting production to meet the quality standards of high-paying premium markets.

In order to ensure real and sustainable results, the project is currently focusing on building the capacities of the Cooperative, said Mr. Vester. At the farm level, the project is working with farmers to make sure productions are high quality products, such as coffee and tea.

Though the project looks promising, some farmers are not fully convinced yet.

In the past, the government had implemented crop substitution programs. However, when the programs failed, farmers were left in trouble, said Ko Khun Oo, secretary general of the Pa-Oh Youth Organization (PYO).

Ten years ago, the Pa-Oh National Army ordered farmers in Hopong, Hsi Hseng and Pinlaung Townships to stop growing poppies. Farmers followed the order and grew garlic instead.

But when farmers came to sell the garlic, there was no market for it. Finally, farmers threw away the garlic and used them to fill the road.

The following year, farmers grew sugar cane, as they thought that the sugar industry would come and buy it from them. But no buyers showed up. “I cried and cried. I learnt a very painful lesson,” said Kun Aung San* from Hopong Township.

Farmers are worried that if they join the ‘Alternative Development Program’ they will face the same disasters, despite the coffee program sounding interesting to them.

THE BEST OF TIMES

This year the poppy price is not as good as in previous years, and many farmers are complaining that they will not get back as much as they invested in growing the crop.

The farmers claim the police’s crackdown on opium growing is one of the factors that have led to the declining price for their yields. As they cannot trade as freely as did previously, some farmers in Kayah State are thinking to switch to growing legal crops.

As many as 30 poppy farmers in Pain Chit Village – a one-hour motorbike ride from Loikaw, the capital of Kayah State – are thinking to give up growing poppies, as they have lost their investment in it this year.

The farmers of this village used to grow garlic, peas, corn, soy bean and paddy, but as they envied farmers from other villages that made huge profits from poppy, they followed suit. Now, they are having second thought, said the village headman.

U Khun Myint Naing, the coordinator of the Myitta Foundation/Kayah State, said that the government should make the best use of the current situation.

“Now is the best time to launch its crop substitution program,” he said.

Though the UNODC is implementing an alternative development program, its coverage is still too small to cover the large cultivation areas of the world’s second largest opium producer.

“There isn’t an adequate crop substitution,” said a poppy farmer in Hopong Township, “[under such situation] asking the farmers to stop growing poppy is like beating us to death.”

(* not real name)

အမျိုးအစား - English (အင်္ဂလိပ်ဘာသာ)

"Myanmar Observer Media Group [MOMG] was founded in 2011 with aims to deeply observe challenging issues of Myanmar, to strongly encourage policy change through in-depth and investigative stories, and to vastly improve journalism skills among local journalists through trainings and workshops. The first edition of Mawkun came out in August 2012 after the censorship board was abolished. The magazine is published in Myanmar Language and its normal size is around 120 pages."