The government established the Advisory Commission on Rakhine State to find a long-lasting solution to the complex and delicate issues in Rakhine State, the western part of the country. Former UN secretary general Kofi Annan heads the commission consisted of three international experts and six Myanmar nationals. But the commission faces criticism from Rakhine nationalists and political parties. Regarding this issue, Mawkun magazine interviewed Rakhine expert Dr. Jacques P. Leider to find out his take on the commission and what can be expected out of the commission.

MAWKUN: What is your take on the new commission that will be led by Kofi Annan?
LEIDER: The State Counsellor has taken the initiative to contact the former Secretary-General of the United Nations, Kofi Annan, to chair an advisory commission on ways to address the complex problems in Rakhine State. Kofi Annan is a highly regarded personality who chairs a foundation that provides help to work towards crisis resolution be it by advocacy, diplomacy or mediation between leaders. One should welcome this initiative because it would be politically unwise if the ethnic peace process made progress nationwide and the situation in Rakhine State were sidelined among the priorities of this government. The commission is a high-profile advisory group, which means that its members bear the responsibility to collect information, listen to opinions and conflictual viewpoints and suggest measures to the government to reduce the conflict and, ideally, work towards reconciliation between the communities.
MAWKUN: Why do you think the new commission was set up? What are pros and cons for setting up the new commission?
LEIDER: We do already know most of the issues on which people do not agree. It is time to work towards exploring what the people on the ground, together with the support of the government, could agree on so as to move Rakhine State towards a better future. I believe that there is already a broad agreement on state-led efforts to improve the rule of law, living conditions and human rights standards. Yet, this is not enough unless the people in Rakhine State themselves feel empowered by the changes.
In the present situation where mutual trust remains weak, the Advisory Commission may help the government and more generally state authorities to develop their thinking about a long-term strategy for Rakhine State. My impression is that the state counselor considers that the commission is not just useful, but necessary. It may also help the Myanmar public opinion to broaden its perception of the Rakhine State issues. Better even, the work of the Advisory Commission could reshape the international view of the complexity of the conflict. The Rakhine State crisis is indeed not only a “Rohingya/Bengali” or an “illegal/maritime migration” problem, but it is the issue of an intensely divided society where both communities have labored in conditions of subjection to the authoritarian state and enduring external economic and political forces since the colonial period. The deeply seated communal discontent has unfortunately disrupted social and political communication.
On the other hand, the government is under pressure by neighbor states about the maritime migrants, the so-called “boat people”, in a regional context that it cannot disregard. The government needs to find an answer how to reconcile its national interests and its international obligations while preventing Rakhine State from becoming a chronic internal problem.
In this complex environment, the work of the Advisory Commission could lead to improved channels of communication and a more comprehensive way of talking about the Rakhine State crisis. Every party that has joined in the discussion over the last four years could gain from the process. In sum, at this moment, I see more pros than cons.
MAWKUN: What differences can be expected between the recommendations of the Rakhine State Conflicts Investigation Commission and those of the new one?
LEIDER: The Advisory Commission led by Mr. Annan has a mission that is clearly defined in time and scope. It enjoys an independent role to make bold suggestions to the government and provide “food for thought” to the competing parties. There is a majority of Myanmar nationals in the commission which ensures that a broad spectrum of views will be included. The Rakhine State Conflicts Investigation Commission, on the other hand, responds to priorities set by the authorities. The media interest for the Annan Commission may at times be greater, but the government itself will be ultimately judged on the score of its own performance and the capacity and effective work of its own commission. The media should, therefore, focus as much on the ongoing work of the Rakhine State Conflicts Investigation Commission.
MAWKUN: Rakhine people are against the new commission, fearing that they’ll lose their right to decide their future. What’s your view on it?
LEIDER: The Commission is an advisory commission, not a decision-making committee. It is composed of highly regarded people and there are Rakhine members on it. I don’t have the feeling that all the Rakhine people are intuitively against the new commission.
Negative reactions have come from those who worry that the Rakhine perceptions and views will be disregarded. This does not surprise me, as the most active Rakhine nationalists have had the strong impression that local Muslim grievances have often gained more credibility with international bodies than their own battle to utter their worries. Two comments can be made in this regard: First, the language of human rights is better understood on an international level than the historical complexity of local political and ethnic discord. Secondly, the Rakhine political class has not yet succeeded to formulate its own vision of Rakhine State’s future in a constructive and positive way.
But 2016 is not 2012. More representatives of the international community have gained experience in the country and are aware that peace and progress in Rakhine State have to be built on cooperation with and listening to the Rakhine ethnic group. Negative reactions such as rejecting the Advisory Commission are mostly driven by fear and lack of determination. It is time for the Rakhine leaders to break out of their self-isolation and engage themselves with the new opportunities. They should remember the lessons of their own history such as the pragmatic policies and diplomacy of Minister Mahapinyakyaw in the 16th century. At that time, and for two centuries, the small Rakhine kingdom became powerful in the region, because it concluded regional political alliances, not because it refused to talk to foreigners!
The foremost duty of the Rakhine political actors is to sketch their visions of the future for Rakhine State and transform them into a workable program. My impression from traveling in the region is that Rakhine youth in Rakhine State, in Yangon Division and in other countries where they work or study, expect their leaders to build the road to a better future. Let it be said that the proverbial Rakhine honesty and tenacity are not obstacles, but can be good tools to stand up for their interests. Finally, politics are the art of the possible. It is thanks to hard negotiations that progress in the country has been made since 2011. This is not different for dealing with issues in Rakhine State. Refusal tactics are simply not enough at this point.
MAWKUN: What challenges are there for the new commission?
LEIDER: Since 2012 Rakhine State issues have been discussed in two different languages: one is the local political language that the Rakhine have used to make clear that their cultural autonomy and religious identity is threatened by a steadily growing Muslim community and that they have had no say in developing their land in the recent past. The other is the international language of human rights standards that puts the political priority on responding to the grievances of the Muslim population (human rights violations and social and political exclusion) and bring to justice culprits of the 2012 clashes. In fact, the political history of Rakhine State since 1948 has been largely dominated by the state’s (or rather the army’s) own “language” that was “security over anything else” and control by constant repression. Obviously, security is a legitimate concern for the state (as USDP’s reaction to the Advisory Commission underscores), but it is precisely decades of state obsession with controlling the people that has produced both human rights violations and the resentment over cultural losses.
The biggest challenge for the Advisory Commission is to bring the terms of these languages together and create a common language where the various interests can be expressed and mutually agreed upon by the government and the conflictual parties. Or put it differently, the challenge is to replace a “winner-takes-it-all” paradigm by a “win-win” paradigm.
MAWKUN: As a Rakhine expert, what would you like to advise the new commission?
LEIDER: The Rakhine State crisis is not just about recent racial animosities or the plight of victims in post-2012 IDP camps as most of the media would suggest when they portray international visitors who flock to Sittway. The core political issue that underlies Rakhine State’s current problems materialized long before the creation of Rakhine State in 1974. It emerged since the moment of Myanmar’s independence in 1948: the question was under what conditions Arakan’s Buddhist Rakhine would co-exist with the mixed and steadily growing Muslim population of old and recent origins. But until the 1960s, this issue was overshadowed by the question of Arakan’s place within the Union. In the first place Rakhine nationalists fought for the creation of their own ethnically denominated state. Yet, at the same time, the Muslim nationalists who stated the existence of an ethnic Rohingya identity, stood up for their own separate Muslim zone that enjoyed a brief existence with the Mayu Frontier Zone (1961-64). For sure, this struggle about competing political projects and the issue of separatism are things of the past and now largely forgotten, but the question how Muslims and Buddhists can and want to live, together or side by side, in the same house called “Rakhine,” is still looming. Probably everyone familiar with the state’s history during the last fifty years will agree that the conditions to discuss and negotiate this issue are unequal and much worse today.
Therefore, in the present situation, it is inevitable that whatever the members of the Advisory Commission will say publicly, it will be understood and interpreted not just as advice potentially guiding the government’s future policies, but also as a call directed at the conflictual parties themselves.

